Last Updated on
Just so you know, this post may contain affiliate links. This means if you make a purchase through links on this page, Canine Weekly may collect a share of the sale or other compensation. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Just like there are many ways to determine different aspects of human intelligence, there are many ways to define and measure intelligence in dogs as well. In 1994, Dr. Stanley Coren conducted a study that has become the professionally accepted measurement of intelligence in dogs. He wrote all about it in his book, The Intelligence of Dogs.
The Intelligence of Dogs
Dr. Coren breaks down canines’ cognitive abilities into three types of dog intelligence:
1. Instinctive Intelligence
This refers to what a dog was bred for. This obviously differs greatly between breeds, but cannot effectively be compared across different breeds.
For example, herding dogs have a high instinctive intelligence for herding animals, scent hounds for following a scent, and Greyhounds for chasing prey by sight.
Guarding, pointing, fetching, and companion instincts are other examples of instinctive intelligence. These different abilities are for the most part innate in a dog and simply require human direction to keep these behaviors pointed in a controlled and productive direction.
2. Adaptive Intelligence
This refers to a dog’s ability to learn and solve problems on its own. Adaptive intelligence can differ significantly within a breed as well as between breeds.
3. Working and Obedience Intelligence
This refers to a dog’s ability to learn from humans, or trainability. Because a dog doing tricks and following commands is often seen as the height of canine intelligence, and because it is easily measured and compared between different dogs and breeds, this type of intelligence is used to rank dog breeds by intelligence.
Trainability does not necessarily indicate intelligence, but we often use it as a proxy for measuring intelligence in dogs. If dogs had not been as willing and able to take direction from humans, we likely never would have domesticated them for the variety of tasks that they currently perform.
Trainability is a combination of a dog’s relationship with people, motivation, and intelligence. A highly trainable dog will enjoy working with people and taking direction from humans, have a high motivation to learn through treats, toys, or other rewards, and be smart enough to understand what his owner is asking him to do.
In humans, this “working and obedience intelligence” is akin to school smarts, whereas “adaptive intelligence” is closer to a person’s creativity or problem-solving skills.
Trainability has to do with intelligence, but it is not a complete test of a dog’s brain. However, it was used as a measurable proxy for canine intelligence by psychologist Stanley Coren.
It is important to remember that the dogs assessed in this study were competing in obedience trial competitions with their trainers. This potentially means that some truly intelligent dogs were paired with mediocre trainers (or an “off day”) that resulted in bad scores or that a somewhat smart dog could be paired with an excellent trainer to get great scores. A responsive and motivated dog will likely perform very well in obedience training with an equally attentive and motivated owner.
Dogs will not rise to be excellently trained on their own, but they will respond very well to positive reinforcement and consistent training practice. A well-trained dog takes a lot of work on the part of the owner, as well as the hound.
In order to make training most successful, you have to:
- Be consistent with the behavior you expect from your dog. Make sure that your training criteria is well-defined. If you don’t know what you’re rewarding, how could your dog?
- Prevent unwanted behavior. Good trainers don’t wait around to correct their dog after a mistake – they do all that they can to prevent their dog from slipping up. This means that they use child locks on their garbage cans, put their dog on a leash when laws and your dog’s skill level require, and separate dogs with baby gates as needed. Trainers call this management.
- Find the perfect reward for your dog, whether that is commercial dog treats, or something tastier, like bits of chicken or cheese. Some dogs are motivated by toys, play, cuddles, and other rewards, so get creative and find out what your dog wants to work for. All dogs are interested in food to some degree – otherwise, they’d starve! That’s why so many trainers use food to train their dogs.
- Challenge your dog regularly. If you stop training your dog once he’s learned sit, down, and stay, he’s unlikely to reach his full potential. Challenge your dog with trick training, puzzle toys, and dog sports relevant to his breed (or whatever he seems to like). Your dog is constantly learning about what works for him (how to get what he wants), so teaching him through training will help him get smarter and help you have a better-behaved dog!
- Keep your training sessions short and sweet. Focusing for long periods of time is hard for any dog, and keeping sessions short will play to his strengths and help him successfully learn any behavior or trick. It will also keep you from getting frustrated at your dog when he gets distracted after learning the same trick for a long period of time. I often do training sessions while I wait for water to boil or during the opening credits of the latest Game of Thrones episode!
- End on a good note. If you start to get frustrated when your dog doesn’t understand or refuses to do a trick, go back to a trick she already knows. Rewarding her for this success and stopping there will keep you both from getting frustrated with training, and ending with a treat will make her want to continue learning from you. Keep it fun!
Again, make sure you are ready to put in the effort to work with your smart dog!
Stanley Coren’s first round of testing used a breed’s performance at AKC obedience competitions to rank each breed in terms of working and obedience intelligence.
In order to find out which dogs had the highest working and obedience intelligence, Stanley Coren decided to ask dog trainers for information. He sent a survey to American Kennel Club and Canadian Kennel Club obedience trial judges. Only the dog breeds that received at least 100 rankings were scored.
This means some rare breeds weren’t represented in the study. Additionally, dog breeds not recognized by the AKC (such as the Jack Russell Terrier) weren’t included in the results. These obedience trial results for over 130 dog breeds have been used to rank these breeds by their intelligence.
The fact that there was a large amount of agreement between judges indicates real, noticeable patterns between breeds. Although this test is by no means a perfect measurement, different methods of assessing canine intelligence have also shown similar patterns.
Later on, Dr. Coren decided to test trainability as an aspect of a dog’s intelligence. Rather than surveying obedience trial judges from the AKC (which means that only dogs with competitive owners, often professional trainers, were measured), this was a survey given to owners.
Of course, there are some downsides to asking owners how smart they think their dogs are. Like with the obedience trial judges, this measure is subject to the skill of the trainer as well as the intelligence of the dog. The results of this survey ranked the dogs within five categories:
- Brightest Dogs: Understand new commands after fewer than 5 repetitions and obey an owner’s first command more than 95% of the time. Dogs within this group included Border Collies and German Shepherd Dogs.
- Excellent Working Dogs: Understand new commands after 5 to 15 repetitions and obey an owner’s first command more than 85% of the time. Dogs within this group included Belgian Sheepdogs and Weimerainers.
- Above Average Working Dogs: Understand new commands after 15 to 25 repetitions and obey an owner’s first command more than 70% of the time. Dogs in this group included Samoyeds and Irish Setters.
- Average Working/Obedience Intelligence: Understand new commands after 25 to 40 repetitions and obey an owner’s first command more than 50% of the time. Pointers and Salukis belong to this group.
- Fair Working/Obedience Intelligence: Understand new commands after 40 to 80 repetitions and obey an owner’s first command more than 30% of the time. Old English Sheepdogs and Bullmastiffs fall into this group.
- Lowest Degree of Working/Obedience Intelligence: Understand new commands after more than 80 repetitions and obey an owner’s first command less than 25% of the time. Chow Chows and Basenjis fall into this group.
Within this system, a breed’s score is determined by the rank they achieved in this study (the “smartest” dog’s score is 1). Although these rankings are widely accepted, it is important to keep in mind that judging some dogs as “excellent working dogs” based on their working/obedience intelligence is often unfair, as dogs were bred to work many different jobs.
If you’d like to do this test on your own with your dog, pick a simple behavior that your dog doesn’t know yet: touching his nose to your hand, for example. See how quickly your dog picks up on this behavior. Watch the video below to learn how to teach your dog this skill.
Then see how well your dog responds to a known cue. Be sure to reward your dog with a treat when he gets things right – otherwise, he’s sure to start ignoring you! Avoid scolding or swatting your dog for getting it wrong, as this will make him less likely to want to work with you later on.
The Bloodhound is difficult to train and is often ranked among the lowest of this list, but you would be hard pressed to find a better working scenthound. Greyhounds are notoriously difficult to teach to sit, not because of their intelligence, but because their body shape makes sitting uncomfortable!
Many canine researchers have a lot of problems with Dr. Coren’s research. His book is often called pseudoscience, relying on poorly-orchestrated surveys at best and folklore or speculation at worst.
Of course, Dr. Coren’s work isn’t the only research out there on canine intelligence. Some research has shown that skull shape and trainability correlates in dogs. The dogs with more moderately shaped heads (not extremely long-nosed or short-nosed) consistently ranked as more intelligent – think the moderately shaped Labrador or German Shepherd head versus the long nose of a Greyhound or the flat face of a Bulldog.
Then again, these researchers admit that this could be based on owner perception or the actual visual capacities based on skull shape, not actual intelligence.
For really interested owners, Adam Milokosi’s book Canine Behavior, Evolution, and Cognition is an incredibly in-depth look at what we know about how smart dogs are, where they come from, and why they do what they do.
As Frans De Waal writes in one of my all-time favorite books, we might just not be smart enough to know how smart animals are. While you can use the tests in Dr. Coren’s study to see how your pup measures up, keep in mind that this is far from a perfect (or even very good) measure of canine intelligence.